PATHFINDER
+

Players who played for both Hibernian and Sheffield United

5 players in our database played for both Hibernian and Sheffield United. 1 of them moved directly between the two clubs (Jim Leighton). The first was Andy Goram (from 1987); the most recent to join the list is Matt Doherty (from 2012).

Before you scroll: how many can you name?

5 players in our list. You get 30 seconds.

At a glance

Moved straight from one to the other

Most league games for Hibernian

Jim Leighton · 151 league games

Most league games for Sheffield United

Clayton Donaldson · 26 league games

Still at one of the two clubs

Positions

Goalkeepers 2 · Forwards 2
PlayerHibernianSheffield United
Matt Doherty2012 (loan)13 apps2026–present2 apps
Jim LeightonGoalkeeper1993–1997151 apps1993 (loan)0 apps
Andy GoramGoalkeeper1987–1991138 apps19987 apps
Anthony StokesForward2009–2010, 2016 (loan), 2017–201872 apps2008–2009 (loan)12 apps
Clayton DonaldsonForward2007–200818 apps2017–201826 apps

Best-known players first. Apps are league appearances, from Wikipedia.

When they arrived

By the decade each player first joined either club.

  • 1980–891
  • 1990–991
  • 2000–092
  • 2010–191

Quick answers

How many players have played for both Hibernian and Sheffield United?
5 players in our database played for both clubs. The best known are Matt Doherty, Jim Leighton and Andy Goram.
Who moved directly between Hibernian and Sheffield United?
From Sheffield United to Hibernian: Jim Leighton.
Who played the most league games for Hibernian and Sheffield United combined?
Jim Leighton, with 151 league games for Hibernian and 0 for Sheffield United (151 in all).
Who is the latest player to play for both Hibernian and Sheffield United?
Matt Doherty, who joined Sheffield United in 2026.
Which players who played for both Hibernian and Sheffield United are still at one of the clubs?
Matt Doherty.

More connections

Looking for another pair? Search any two clubs

Try it without the list

Two clubs, 45 seconds: how many players who played for both can you name?

Or a club quiz: Sheffield United

Covers the 5 players in Football Pathfinder’s database, not every player in history. Career data from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).