PATHFINDER
+

Players who played for both Everton and Sheffield United

24 players in our database played for both Everton and Sheffield United. 9 of them moved directly between the two clubs. The first was Adrian Heath (from 1982); the most recent to join the list is Robin Olsen (from 2020).

Before you scroll: how many can you name?

24 players in our list. You get 30 seconds.

At a glance

Moved straight from one to the other

Most league games for Everton

Phil Jagielka · 322 league games

Most league games for Sheffield United

Phil Jagielka · 270 league games

Positions

Goalkeepers 3 · Defenders 5 · Midfielders 8 · Forwards 4
PlayerEvertonSheffield United
Phil JagielkaDefender2007–2019322 apps2000–2007, 2019–2021270 apps
Dominic Calvert-LewinForward2016–2025239 apps201411 apps
Gary SpeedMidfielder1996–199858 apps2008–201037 apps
Muhamed BešićMidfielder2014–202137 apps2019–2020 (loan)9 apps
Jack Rodwell2007–201285 apps2020–20211 app
Robin OlsenGoalkeeper2020–2021 (loan)7 apps2021–2022 (loan)11 apps
Conor Coady2022–2023 (loan)24 apps2013–2014 (loan)39 apps
Iliman NdiayeForward2024–202667 apps2019–202377 apps
Richard WrightGoalkeeper2002–200760 apps2010–20112 apps
Tom DaviesMidfielder2015–2023155 apps2023–202632 apps
James BeattieForward2005–200776 apps2007–2009, 2011–201280 apps
David Carney2002–20030 apps2007–200921 apps
Ben GodfreyDefender2020–202482 apps2025–2026 (loan)4 apps
Marcus BentForward2004–200655 apps1999–2000, 2011 (loan)59 apps
Stuart McCallMidfielder1988–1991103 apps2002–200571 apps
Li TieMidfielder2002–200634 apps2006–20080 apps
Jose BaxterMidfielder2008–2011, 2017–20187 apps2013–201693 apps
John LundstramMidfielder2012–20130 apps2017–2021108 apps
Iain TurnerGoalkeeper2003–20114 apps2014–201511 apps
Kieran DowellMidfielder2014–20172 apps2019 (loan)16 apps
Gary AblettDefender1992–1996128 apps1996 (loan)12 apps
Adrian Heath1982–1988226 apps1995–19964 apps
Earl BarrettDefender1995–199874 apps1998 (loan)5 apps
Terry PhelanDefender1997–200025 apps20018 apps

Best-known players first. Apps are league appearances, from Wikipedia.

Team-mates on this list

Players who played for both clubs and were at one of them in the same seasons.

When they arrived

By the decade each player first joined either club.

  • 1980–892
  • 1990–995
  • 2000–098
  • 2010–197
  • 2020–292

Quick answers

How many players have played for both Everton and Sheffield United?
24 players in our database played for both clubs. The best known are Phil Jagielka, Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Gary Speed.
Who moved directly between Everton and Sheffield United?
From Everton to Sheffield United: Phil Jagielka, Robin Olsen, Tom Davies, James Beattie and Li Tie and 2 more. From Sheffield United to Everton: Phil Jagielka and Jose Baxter.
Who played the most league games for Everton and Sheffield United combined?
Phil Jagielka, with 322 league games for Everton and 270 for Sheffield United (592 in all).
Who is the latest player to play for both Everton and Sheffield United?
Ben Godfrey, who joined Sheffield United in 2025.

More connections

Looking for another pair? Search any two clubs

Try it without the list

Two clubs, 45 seconds: how many players who played for both can you name?

Or a club quiz: Everton · Sheffield United

Covers the 24 players in Football Pathfinder’s database, not every player in history. Career data from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).