Players who played for both Everton and Sheffield United
24 players in our database played for both Everton and Sheffield United. 9 of them moved directly between the two clubs. The first was Adrian Heath (from 1982); the most recent to join the list is Robin Olsen (from 2020).
Before you scroll: how many can you name?
24 players in our list. You get 30 seconds.
At a glance
Best-known names
Moved straight from one to the other
- Everton → Sheffield United: 7
- Sheffield United → Everton: Phil Jagielka, Jose Baxter
Most league games for Everton
Most league games for Sheffield United
Positions
| Player | Everton | Sheffield United |
|---|---|---|
| Phil JagielkaDefender | 2007–2019322 apps | 2000–2007, 2019–2021270 apps |
| Dominic Calvert-LewinForward | 2016–2025239 apps | 201411 apps |
| Gary SpeedMidfielder | 1996–199858 apps | 2008–201037 apps |
| Muhamed BešićMidfielder | 2014–202137 apps | 2019–2020 (loan)9 apps |
| Jack Rodwell | 2007–201285 apps | 2020–20211 app |
| Robin OlsenGoalkeeper | 2020–2021 (loan)7 apps | 2021–2022 (loan)11 apps |
| Conor Coady | 2022–2023 (loan)24 apps | 2013–2014 (loan)39 apps |
| Iliman NdiayeForward | 2024–202667 apps | 2019–202377 apps |
| Richard WrightGoalkeeper | 2002–200760 apps | 2010–20112 apps |
| Tom DaviesMidfielder | 2015–2023155 apps | 2023–202632 apps |
| James BeattieForward | 2005–200776 apps | 2007–2009, 2011–201280 apps |
| David Carney | 2002–20030 apps | 2007–200921 apps |
| Ben GodfreyDefender | 2020–202482 apps | 2025–2026 (loan)4 apps |
| Marcus BentForward | 2004–200655 apps | 1999–2000, 2011 (loan)59 apps |
| Stuart McCallMidfielder | 1988–1991103 apps | 2002–200571 apps |
| Li TieMidfielder | 2002–200634 apps | 2006–20080 apps |
| Jose BaxterMidfielder | 2008–2011, 2017–20187 apps | 2013–201693 apps |
| John LundstramMidfielder | 2012–20130 apps | 2017–2021108 apps |
| Iain TurnerGoalkeeper | 2003–20114 apps | 2014–201511 apps |
| Kieran DowellMidfielder | 2014–20172 apps | 2019 (loan)16 apps |
| Gary AblettDefender | 1992–1996128 apps | 1996 (loan)12 apps |
| Adrian Heath | 1982–1988226 apps | 1995–19964 apps |
| Earl BarrettDefender | 1995–199874 apps | 1998 (loan)5 apps |
| Terry PhelanDefender | 1997–200025 apps | 20018 apps |
Best-known players first. Apps are league appearances, from Wikipedia.
Team-mates on this list
Players who played for both clubs and were at one of them in the same seasons.
- Dominic Calvert-Lewin + Phil Jagielka at Everton, 2016–2019
- Muhamed Bešić + Phil Jagielka at Everton, 2014–2019
- Muhamed Bešić + Phil Jagielka at Sheffield United, 2019–2020
- Jack Rodwell + Phil Jagielka at Everton, 2007–2012
- Jack Rodwell + Phil Jagielka at Sheffield United, 2020–2021
- Iliman Ndiaye + Phil Jagielka at Sheffield United, 2019–2021
- Dominic Calvert-Lewin + Muhamed Bešić at Everton, 2016–2021
- Dominic Calvert-Lewin + Robin Olsen at Everton, 2020–2021
When they arrived
By the decade each player first joined either club.
- 1980–892
- 1990–995
- 2000–098
- 2010–197
- 2020–292
Quick answers
- How many players have played for both Everton and Sheffield United?
- 24 players in our database played for both clubs. The best known are Phil Jagielka, Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Gary Speed.
- Who moved directly between Everton and Sheffield United?
- From Everton to Sheffield United: Phil Jagielka, Robin Olsen, Tom Davies, James Beattie and Li Tie and 2 more. From Sheffield United to Everton: Phil Jagielka and Jose Baxter.
- Who played the most league games for Everton and Sheffield United combined?
- Phil Jagielka, with 322 league games for Everton and 270 for Sheffield United (592 in all).
- Who is the latest player to play for both Everton and Sheffield United?
- Ben Godfrey, who joined Sheffield United in 2025.
More connections
Looking for another pair? Search any two clubs
Try it without the list
Two clubs, 45 seconds: how many players who played for both can you name?
Or a club quiz: Everton · Sheffield United
Covers the 24 players in Football Pathfinder’s database, not every player in history. Career data from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).