PATHFINDER
+

Players who played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United

7 players in our database played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United. 1 of them moved directly between the two clubs (Tim Krul). The first was Bryan 'Pop' Robson (from 1962); the most recent to join the list is Paul Dummett (from 2010).

Before you scroll: how many can you name?

7 players in our list. You get 30 seconds.

At a glance

Moved straight from one to the other

Nobody moved straight between the two clubs.

Most league games for Carlisle United

Mark Gillespie · 161 league games

Most league games for Newcastle United

Peter Beardsley · 276 league games

Still at one of the two clubs

Positions

Goalkeepers 2 · Defenders 1 · Midfielders 1 · Forwards 1
PlayerCarlisle UnitedNewcastle United
Tim KrulGoalkeeper2008–2009 (loan)9 apps2006–2016160 apps
Peter Beardsley1979–1982104 apps1983–1987, 1993–1997276 apps
Paul Dummett20253 apps2010–2024196 apps
James TavernierDefender2011 (loan)16 apps2009–20112 apps
Bryan 'Pop' RobsonForward1981–1982, 1982–1983 (loan), 1984–198572 apps1962–1971206 apps
David McCreeryMidfielder1992–199439 apps1982–1989272 apps
Mark GillespieGoalkeeper2010–2017161 apps2020–present0 apps

Best-known players first. Apps are league appearances, from Wikipedia.

Team-mates on this list

Players who played for both clubs and were at one of them in the same seasons.

When they arrived

By the decade each player first joined either club.

  • 1960–691
  • 1970–791
  • 1980–891
  • 2000–092
  • 2010–192

Quick answers

How many players have played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
7 players in our database played for both clubs. The best known are Tim Krul, Peter Beardsley and Paul Dummett.
Who moved directly between Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
Nobody in our database went straight from Carlisle United to Newcastle United or back; every player had at least one other club in between.
Who played the most league games for Carlisle United and Newcastle United combined?
Peter Beardsley, with 104 league games for Carlisle United and 276 for Newcastle United (380 in all).
Who is the latest player to play for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
Paul Dummett, who joined Carlisle United in 2025.
Which players who played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United are still at one of the clubs?
Mark Gillespie.

More connections

Looking for another pair? Search any two clubs

Try it without the list

Two clubs, 45 seconds: how many players who played for both can you name?

Or a club quiz: Newcastle United

Covers the 7 players in Football Pathfinder’s database, not every player in history. Career data from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).