Players who played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United
7 players in our database played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United. 1 of them moved directly between the two clubs (Tim Krul). The first was Bryan 'Pop' Robson (from 1962); the most recent to join the list is Paul Dummett (from 2010).
Before you scroll: how many can you name?
7 players in our list. You get 30 seconds.
At a glance
Best-known names
Moved straight from one to the other
Most league games for Carlisle United
Most league games for Newcastle United
Still at one of the two clubs
Positions
| Player | Carlisle United | Newcastle United |
|---|---|---|
| Tim KrulGoalkeeper | 2008–2009 (loan)9 apps | 2006–2016160 apps |
| Peter Beardsley | 1979–1982104 apps | 1983–1987, 1993–1997276 apps |
| Paul Dummett | 20253 apps | 2010–2024196 apps |
| James TavernierDefender | 2011 (loan)16 apps | 2009–20112 apps |
| Bryan 'Pop' RobsonForward | 1981–1982, 1982–1983 (loan), 1984–198572 apps | 1962–1971206 apps |
| David McCreeryMidfielder | 1992–199439 apps | 1982–1989272 apps |
| Mark GillespieGoalkeeper | 2010–2017161 apps | 2020–present0 apps |
Best-known players first. Apps are league appearances, from Wikipedia.
Team-mates on this list
Players who played for both clubs and were at one of them in the same seasons.
- Paul Dummett + Tim Krul at Newcastle United, 2010–2016
- James Tavernier + Tim Krul at Newcastle United, 2009–2011
- James Tavernier + Paul Dummett at Newcastle United, 2010–2011
- Bryan 'Pop' Robson + Peter Beardsley at Carlisle United, 1981–1982
- David McCreery + Peter Beardsley at Newcastle United, 1983–1987
- Mark Gillespie + Paul Dummett at Newcastle United, 2020–2024
When they arrived
By the decade each player first joined either club.
- 1960–691
- 1970–791
- 1980–891
- 2000–092
- 2010–192
Quick answers
- How many players have played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
- 7 players in our database played for both clubs. The best known are Tim Krul, Peter Beardsley and Paul Dummett.
- Who moved directly between Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
- Nobody in our database went straight from Carlisle United to Newcastle United or back; every player had at least one other club in between.
- Who played the most league games for Carlisle United and Newcastle United combined?
- Peter Beardsley, with 104 league games for Carlisle United and 276 for Newcastle United (380 in all).
- Who is the latest player to play for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United?
- Paul Dummett, who joined Carlisle United in 2025.
- Which players who played for both Carlisle United and Newcastle United are still at one of the clubs?
- Mark Gillespie.
More connections
- Carlisle United and Sunderland
- Carlisle United and Huddersfield Town
- Carlisle United and Manchester United
- Carlisle United and Queens Park Rangers
- Carlisle United and Derby County
- Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspur
- Newcastle United and Queens Park Rangers
- Newcastle United and Nottingham Forest
- Newcastle United and Manchester City
- Newcastle United and Sunderland
Looking for another pair? Search any two clubs
Try it without the list
Two clubs, 45 seconds: how many players who played for both can you name?
Or a club quiz: Newcastle United
Covers the 7 players in Football Pathfinder’s database, not every player in history. Career data from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).